On the Topic of Balance

So I was at this Pagan Ritual today...
Somehow, that comes out as kind of a "And three pagans walk into a bar" kind of joke.
I go for some political reasons; it's interesting to support others in a minority culture and the church (Universalist Unitarian) where the ritual is held hosts some very nice folk. My friends and I have been able to use the space in the past to handle our own public rites, more animist in nature (people apparently love our theatrics
). And with that, I start again...
So I was at this Pagan Ritual today. The time of year is the Autumn Equinox and they're going on about typical farmer stuff (God is the Grain, the Mother is the Grain, Blessed be the Breadmaker, etc.) but the crux of their ritual is about Balance. How do you balance your life, balance your energies, balance your checkbook, balance anything?! Well, with this ritual, of course! The spirits will be happy and everything will come to a happy medium.
Only (and this is what I was reflecting on), there is no such thing as balance in the world around us. Everything works as a constant, consistent, wonderful, energetic dynamic, always teetering on a pleasantly adventuresome edge, waiting to exploit or back off from some unexpected shift. Life isn't about a static sort of balance; it's about harmonizing -- finding the tune, the wavelength, the beat that fits in with the moment and when it changes, you groove along with it.
Which, of course, led me to thinking, where does this idea of a static balance from from, this concrete yin, yang, unchanging except in regular (the sun rises, the sun sets) or dramatic (crap. the sun didn't rise
) sort of ways?
An answer hit me like the proverbial ton of clay fired, organic, sustainably harvested bricks. In catastrophe farming (as opposed to succession farming), you really possess only two states: (1) the land is growing food or (2) the land is not growing food. That's why weeds (non-food catastrophe plants) are so 'evil'; they take you to State #2.
This is a simple, observable phenomenon that could have been internalized and then mythologized back in Ye Olden Times. Balance -- starvation will come but hey, food can come to (yea catastrophe plants!)!
Some may question (my sanity... oops; just speaking aloud again) why I think about such things; I do this to try and trace threads of culture back to their sources, to try and sort out what might be an sustainable dynamic mode of thought and what can be cut as a destructive/non-useable segment of mother culture.
So screw the idea of "out of balance." Screw "balance!" Hell, let's lump in peace there as well (peace being defined as the absence of war)! Here's to harmony folks! Here's to the eternal song and dance that winds its way through the universe.
Best
Bill Maxwell
Author, Activist, Animist
Currently, a little on the rant-y side.

Ah yep....
Hey --
I agree with you totally Bill... as I was reading and you posed the question that is EXACTLY what went through my head....
Add to that... once the perception switched into a dicotomous mode, well, that makes things a whole lot easier when your goal is control over the world. It's a whole lot easier to think in terms of balance, of good and bad and so forth than it is to think in systems. Maybe that is why my own approach to animism (although I think I prefer the term monist for myself, because of the differences in my 'theology') has paralleled my intuitive grasping of systemic thinking 
Janene

balance shmalance
Yeah, though I sometimes self-identify as a "neopagan" or "pagan" I don't get with the balance thing either. Probably because my pagan diety archtype is Trickster, who doesn't fit into the balance picture, but rather the shaking things off-balance thingy.
I don't see things dichotomously, but as more of a wad o' different stuffs.
What's the opposite of wombat?

On Tricksters & Opposites
I'm "lucky" in that where I live the Trickster is the deity / spirit / concept who created (and still assists) man & is as much a hero as someone likely to get in trouble (wait... isn't that the definition of a hero? Heh).
The opposite of wombat is Tabmow, isn't it? Or would that be "Wat Mob?!" (quick! hide!)
"Change comes from giving up the myth that you are in control."

On Cheating... ;)
<>Um... yes, that would be him. Is he <choke> seeing you too? <sob>
"Change comes from giving up the myth that you are in control."

Random Pagany Goodness?
Sounds like the words that are being looked for are 'dynamic equalibrium'.
Your 'State A, State B' idea sounds very Claude Levi-Straus, which while occasionally interesting, he seems to miss the mark more often than not. Not everybody thinks in diachotomies, or if they do, not everything they think about is put in those terms. Well maybe corn farmers are like that, since corn is such a 'fire and forget' crop, but I always hear from the farmers I work with "Well now its time to do this, and soon ill have to do another thing."
I tend to cringe when i'm around other pagans for long enough. Why is this? Its probably because for a group of people who expose the idea that the world is a sacred place, many of them either lack fundimental knowledge about where their stuff comes from, or ignorantly continue activities that flagrantly and obviously destructive to the self and destructive to the world around them. All this while they talk about universal love and light and if we had enough 'light workers' that things would just turn around.

sitting in the middle
dammit man, why can't we live closer to one another. ) :
there is a large (dur hur hur Salem) pagan community here, and it is very much as you describe it in your homeplace.
but it's new england. farming was big here back in the day. it is still seen as the ultimate 'escape' for people who want to live 'off the land'. ... but there are no more acres left. the fish are so full of mercury that i can safely eat about 8 oz. a month.
when i learned about animism clearly (thanks to Story of B), i did suddenly hear all those things about mother grain, harvest and planting and fertility. it is actually disruptive for me in ritual... but i can't say much. i'm the odd one out, and their entire religion depends on the grain (even if figuratively and not literally).
once, i got to host (acting priestess) a large gathering of my pagan friends from a coven we had going. i mixed the two ways effectively, i think. Hawk even came while we looked at the heavens, grounding. I asked the (regular/high) priestess if she had anything more to add. she asked a very pagan raised child if they wanted to say anything... the child replied by pointing at hawk, and saying "go away".
i know, it's just out of the mouth of babes... but the priestess then echoed it. "Go Away".
pained, i left the group a month later, and it dissolved shortly after that.
i guess what i'm saying is, it's so lonely being 'animist', unless you've a group ie. 'tribe' to be in. if you must be in a group (and i am now), pagans are likely the most accepting. they won't push their particular way upon you, but universally, they still speak of the agricultural 'givens' of balance, good and evil, worshipping this to be saved from that....
GF
--
Look, Ishmael... are you sore at me or something?

loneliness
I use to think I was lonely before I read Ishmael, now I wish I had never come across it because then I could just be one of the happy ignorant people building the pyramid in peace. To have a 'changed mind' means a lifetime condemed to isolation and loneliness.

Lonely? There's a world out there...
One of the things that transformed my life after reading the Ish stuff was realizing that there was an entire WORLD out there waiting to talk to me -- and now it talks back. It's still an overwhelming and wonderful experience.
If you're referring to people, though, talk to the elements within your world for a time and then ask if they can help you find some humans with similar minds to talk to -- that's what I did & wow things changed. I just have to take advantage of it now and I may have a number of local friends.
You are not alone.
(worse comes to worst, come visit some time; we'll kvetch about Mother Culture and share a glass of tea and my children can dance around and warm your heart about the future)
Best
Bill Maxwell
"Change comes from giving up the myth that you are in control."


hey this is cool, reminds me
hey this is cool, reminds me of two things that's happened in my life recently.
one, how I've been breaking out my favorite phrase a lot to help friends in need: "I practice moderation in moderation"
and... I don't remember the other one, how's that for balance?